BALANCE CONE PHOTO GALLERY
A selection of photos taken at the balance cone restoration ceremony by Alan Bull, reproduced by permission of Historic England.
All images copyright (c) Historic Egland, 2024.
A selection of photos taken at the balance cone restoration ceremony by Alan Bull, reproduced by permission of Historic England.
All images copyright (c) Historic Egland, 2024.
Millions of years ago cracks in the folded rock at Ecton were filled by hot metal-bearing water from great depths (photo shows folded rocks with calcite filling cracks). As this cooled copper, lead, and zinc ores were deposited in a series of near-vertical deposits. Two of these, the ‘Deep Ecton Pipe’ and the ‘Clayton Pipe’ as short distance to the south, were very rich and went vertically in sinuous fashion from the hilltop down to great depths. There were long-standing rumours, perhaps based on only wishful thinking, that there was a third rich ‘pipe’ at Ecton. Despite much money and hard work spent in efforts to locate it, this was never found.
The most common copper ore was chalcopyrite, while those of lead and zinc were galena and blende, but in addition there are many other minerals that existed in smaller quantities.
Copper fetched a much greater price than the other metals found at Ecton and was a vital element for making bronze and brass. In prehistory copper was often combined with tin to make bronze tools and weapons. However, another intriguing possibility is that the copper ores were used as pigments, as when oxidised near surface these ores included bright green malachite and intense blue azurite. In much later times copper was used for such things as lining the bottoms of warships, producing low-value coinage and making sculpture.
Chalcopyrite was the primary copper ore mined from Deep Ecton mine, similar in appearance to pyrite which is sometimes known as “fool’s gold”, though of course neither mineral contains any gold. Pyrite is an iron sulphide, while chalcopyrite is a copper and iron sulphide.
The building on the ridgetop started life as the ‘house’ for a steam engine designed by James Watt and used to bring ores from depth up to river level; it was built in 1788 and is the oldest surviving mine winding house in the world. The engine was used until at least the 1830s and probably to about 1850. The window and door were added after the engine was scrapped; if you look carefully at the four sides of the building, most of the original walled-up openings can still be seen. The photograph was taken before the balance cone was restored in 2023.
The 1788 steam engine had two interconnecting winding drums outside, one with a rope that went down the main shaft to the depths of the mine, the other to a shaft that had counterbalance weights. The latter was a 1789 afterthought added after the original weights in the main shaft plummeted to the bottom of the mine. To ensure no loss of life and interruptions to the mining, they sank a new shaft for these. The only viable place for this shaft was downslope and its top had to be raised by building a huge cone of rubble to support the pulley and its frame.
The steam engine broke down from time to time. Thus, a horse-operated winding drum, here from the 1760s, was retained as a back-up system when the steam winding engine was installed.
This old photograph was taken before the engine house roof 
was lowered on one side and it was converted to a field barn. The steam engine was located in the far half of the building, while its boiler was in the near half. A short distance upslope there was a small reservoir pond for the boilers fed by water brought up from the mine.
The dilapidated balance cone has stone facing on its downslope half, placed here as a wrap-around buttress sometime in the first thirty years to prevent the structure collapsing. The shaft was covered by a stone beehive cap to protect livestock after the engine was scrapped in the 1850s.
In the 1760s-80s the internationally important Deep Ecton Copper Mine made a fortune for the Dukes of Devonshire. The first copper was mined here long before, in the Bronze Age over 3,500 years ago. The Dukes, who owned northern and western parts of the hill, had their mines worked in-house for over 50 years from 1760. From the 1820s private mining companies embarked on a fruitless search for further rich ore deposits. The mines were finally abandoned in 1889. While the 19th century ventures lost investors’ money, with them at best only finding other peoples’ leavings, they kept local miners in work for decades.
The Duke’s mine was the deepest in Britain in the 18th century. It descended to well below sea level, reaching 300m under the River Manifold. The mine was deeper than the Eiffel Tower is high and had workings, in places so large, that miners could not see from one side to the other as they worked by candlelight in an atmosphere thick with dust and smoke from gunpowder.
The Deep Ecton Mine elevation is based on one drawn in 1858 and is the best that survives. As recent dives have confirmed, the drawing is schematic in the sense that features shown are in front of or behind others and these are sometimes not directly linked to each other. For instance, the underground canal went behind the main ore workings rather than passing through them.
The interpretation panel is next to the outdoor classrooms of the Geoff Cox Study Centre that are used by schools from across Britain. In the 1970s Geoff, a mining engineer, founded this to inspire students to take an interest in minerals and modern mining. Teaching at school and university levels has continued to today run by the volunteer teachers of the Ecton Hill Field Studies Association. The Ecton Mine Educational Trust now owns and manages the Deep Ecton Mine, supporting the teachers as well as enabling use of the mine for scientific research. Visit https://ectonhillfsa.org and https://ectonmine.org.uk.
In recent years Deep Ecton Mine has been used for scientific research. This has included exploring the vast workings now flooded below the level of the Manifold River using experimental submersible robots developed by a multi-national team. To date these have reached depths of 127m and 113m in the pumping and winding shafts but they were unfortunately stopped here by blockages. Higher up, a massive flooded chamber created in the 1740s to 1760s was explored, located above the horizon of the underground canal. Open leads exist both here and in side passages that will require robots with more sophisticated exploration capacities. Details discoveries have included wooden platforms, miners’ ladders, a chain handrail for a bridge across a deep void and a set of miners’ initials picked into a passage wall in the 1700s. Visit https://unexmin.eu and https://unexup.eu.
Other scientific research has included the use of ground-penetrating radar to search for lost ancient mine workings on the ridgetop and the testing of laser scanning equipment in the unflooded workings.
The powder house, where dangerous explosives were stored. This small shed was placed well away from other buildings and was erected in 1884. The interior was originally lined with wooden panels as an added precaution against accidentally creating sparks.
This large back wall for a building on top of the massive main waste heap was erected in the 1880s and used to separate the ores from waste rock before smelting. The two hoppers behind were used to store ore ready for processing. They had been processing the ores from the ‘Deep Ecton Mine’ at this spot from the 1750s at latest, brought up shafts to this level. The dumped processing waste extends down to the valley bottom. In the 1760s after the Duke of Devonshire took over the mines on his land, he had copper, lead and slag smelters built by the river that took up much of the ground here. However, in the 1770s the massive quantities of copper ore were taken to a new smelter at Whiston near Cheadle, as there were coal mines there for fuel and the processed copper could be shipped out by the then new Caldon Canal.
The ridgetop, illustrated here by an archaeological plan made in 2008, had shallow copper workings dug over 3,500 years ago and was mined again in the 17th Century when Ecton was one of the first mines in Britain to use gunpowder to break rock.
The prehistoric mining was done using antler tines as picks, animal bones as scrapers and cobbles from the river as hammers. These ancient workings were reworked by Jacob Mumma in 1665-68, who brought the new extraction technique of using explosives in drilled holes from the continent. From his time onwards this part of the hill became known as Dutchman Mine.
The 1788 steam engine had two interconnecting winding drums outside, one with a rope that went down the main shaft to the depths of the mine, the other to a shaft that had counterbalance weights. The latter was a 1789 afterthought added after the original weights in the main shaft plummeted to the bottom of the mine. To ensure no loss of life and interruptions to the mining, they sank a new shaft for these. The only viable place for this shaft was downslope and its top had to be raised by building a huge cone of rubble to support the pulley and its frame.
The steam engine broke down from time to time. Thus, a horse-operated winding drum, here from the 1760s, was retained as a back-up system when the steam winding engine was installed.
This old photograph was taken before the engine house roof was lowered on one side and it was converted to a field barn. The steam engine was located in the far half of the building, while its boiler was in the near half. A short distance upslope there was a small reservoir pond for the boilers fed by water brought up from the mine.
The dilapidated balance cone has stone facing on its downslope half, placed here as a wrap-around buttress sometime in the first thirty years to prevent the structure collapsing. The shaft was covered by a stone beehive cap to protect livestock after the engine was scrapped in the 1850s.
In their heyday the mines employed hundreds of miners on short-term six to seven week contracts. If the mine manager did not need them they got no work and often if they found no ore they got no pay. Their life was hard, they walked to and from local villages to reach the mine and sometimes climbed down hundreds of metres on ladders to get to where the ore was being worked.
There were seventeen separate mines of various sizes documented as being worked in the 1700s and 1800s at Ecton. There were well over fifty mine entry points in former times but these are now mostly collapsed or filled in; the ones that remain are gated or grilled.
There are still impressive chambers underground, including this one at the adjacent Clayton Mine used for steam engines. Here ores were wound up from depth, while pumps attached to the main engine controlled the water levels deep in the mine. A second engine next to the chamber was used to compress air for rock drills, while a third produced electricity for lighting.
In Deep Ecton Mine there was a large early-1780s chamber for pumping engines that was placed deep under the hilltop at river horizon. The first one installed had a rocking beam powered by water brought along a horizontal passage driven especially from upriver at Ape Tor. This was replaced in 1823 by a massive waterwheel. Both were classic examples of 18th and 19th century green technology.
At the top of the large waste heap surrounded by trees, behind a steel door, there is a flooded passage that originally ran under much of Ecton Hill, which was created in the 1850s to search without success for more rich ore deposits.
The first passage here, started before 1760, was ‘Dutchman Level’ that explored under nearby old ridegetop workings. About a century later this was extended as ‘Goodhope Level’ and despite the name again it failed to live up to expectations. The rock removed as the passages were being driven was tipped down the hillside from the entrance.
A mathematical geologist with over 50 years background in computer applications, and long experience in providing services to the mining industry on 6 continents. After working for national geological surveys in Australia and the UK in the 1970s, he was co-founder of DATAMINE and has run his own geological software and mining consultancy businesses since 1981. This has included extensive work with the minerals industry in Russia and central Asia, as well as contract research with the British Geological Survey and with CSIRO in Australia.
Recently retired from commercial project work, he is still active in EU-funded research and innovation projects, particularly concerned with development of robotic methods for underground mines.
Julian has worked in the extractives industry all his life. After graduating from the University of Leeds with a BSc in Quarrying he focussed on operational management. He ran a range of mineral extractives
sites throughout the UK but more recently managed multi million tonne operations in the Middle East. Latterly he joined the Institute of Quarrying as Head of Educational and Standards working closely with stakeholders and educational institutions to develop and run a range a qualifications and training for the industry. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Quarrying and a Fellow of the Higher Education Academy in the UK and holds a Post Grad Diploma in Education.
A Chartered Mining Engineer working worldwide on mining and construction projects. Strong links to Derbyshire mining, having previously managed local fluorspar and lead mines and a long serving Juryman for the Great Barmote Court.
Peter has nearly 50 years experience mostly at the sharp end of the minerals industry. He is a metallurgist who started in the steel industry prior to his degree at Cambridge University. He held senior positions with Anglo American on the Zambian Copperbelt, and at Glebe Mines fluorspar operation in the Derbyshire Peak District; and has been an independent freelance since 2000. He has had connections with Ecton Mine and Geoff Cox since the mid-1980s. He is Secretary of The British Aggregates Association, a member of the CBI Minerals Group and the UK National Minerals Forum; and has various business interests in the industrial minerals industry in the UK, Europe and globally; and is also a Director of MAUK (Mining Association of the UK) and Amemptos Music.
I am an exploration and mining geologist (C. Geol) with over 25 years of experience in the deep geological disposal of radioactive waste and 7 years of experience of exploration, environmental impact assessment and mining feasibility for the Kayelekera uranium deposit in Northern Malawi, Africa. I retired from the British Geological Survey in 2016 and am currently a member of the Government’s Committee on Radioactive Waste Disposal. I undertook a PhD on caves and mines in the Peak District and, as an active caver and mine explorer, have been studying the underground world of the Peak District since the mid 1970’s, including the mines of the Ecton Area. I am a director (editor) of the Peak District Mines Historical Society and the mine manager of their Temple Mine in Matlock Bath.
Ruth Allington has more than 38 years of experience as a consultant to the construction raw materials sector, specialising in the evaluation of resources and reserves and in the responsible design of quarries and pits to recover them. In addition to her BSc and MSc degrees, she also has an MBA, and she is a qualified commercial and community mediator and facilitator and experienced expert witness. Ruth is the current President of the Geological Society of London.
She is committed to promoting the highest professional standards a
mongst geologists and others involved in the application of geoscience, particularly through the promotion of professional titles such as CEng, CGeol, and EurGeol. She has served on the Council of the Geological Society of London and is a past President of the European Federation of Geologists. For many years, she has been a member of the Pan European Reserves and Resources Reporting Committee (PERC).
She is passionate about promoting ‘joined up thinking’ and encouraging collaborative approaches to problem definition, problem solving and dispute resolution based on effective communication and co-operation between the wide range of professional disciplines involved in quarry design, planning and management, and also in facilitating effective communication between the public and operators or developers (and their advisors). A particular interest is in mentoring of students and young professionals aspiring to commence or progress careers in geoscience and mining.
M
Phil in Organic Chemistry, Nottingham Uni 1977-79, awarded 1981
Editorial Assistant/Information Scientist for the Royal Society of Chemistry 1981-89, Freelance scientific literature work 1989-91, PGCE Science/Chemistry teaching 1991-92, Science/Chemistry Teacher Rushcliffe School 1992-2008, Chemistry Teacher Nottingham Girls’ High School 2008-16 (Retirement)
I attended Ecton Mine on Field Trips with NGHS for the last 5-6 years, maybe more. On my last “working” visit, I was invited to become a Tutor, which I readily accepted. After a brief period of training, including requirements for underground visits to Salt’s Level, I started assisting with school visits
I am a geoscientist with more than 45 years of experience. After working as a mine geologist in the Yorkshire Coalfield for 12 years, I moved on to seismic exploration for coal, potash and other minerals focussing on seismic interpretation and delineating geological structure to aid mine planning. My prospect experience includes projects in UK, Spain, Turkey, Australia, Africa, Argentina and Canada.
With a background as a mining engineer I moved into the world of professional bodies responsible for the professional standards and competence of individuals practicing in mini
ng and engineering around the world. Although I am now retired I continue to hold Board appointments with national and international regulatory and standards organisations which I find professionally stimulating and thoroughly rewarding.
My direction in life was established while still at school and was in no small part due to Ecton Mine which enthralled me from the time I first heard of it from Geoff Cox who then owned it. Almost 40 years later, and ravaged by time (see pic), I had the opportunity to become a founding trustee of EMET and to put something back into Ecton Mine to which I owe so much.